Paper · MFC
Efficacy of bioelectrochemical and electrochemical systems in ammonia recovery from slaughterhouse wastewater
Summary
What the paper reports, in its own words.
Abstract
Abstract Ammonia presence in water has many negative impacts including eutrophication. So, the major objective of this research was to evaluate the efficiency of microbial fuel cell (MFC) and electrochemical (ECS) systems for their removal and/or recovery from wastewater at different levels of ammonia (500 ppm, 1000 ppm, and 1500 ppm). Additionally, a novel approach was tested by using nanomaterial prepared from pomegranate peel as a coating material for the electrodes as it is abundant in many countries. Two systems were tested: Group (A) with a non-coated graphite plate anode (MFC1 and ECS1) and Group (B) which was coated with nano-graphene oxide made from pomegranate peels (MFC2 and ECS2). Results revealed that MFC1 gave the best ammonia removal efficiency reaching 96.2% when the initial concentration was 500 ppm after 13 days, and MFC2 gave maximum removal efficiency of 94.4% and 99.4% for 1000 and 1500 ppm after 19 and 25 days, respectively. COD results coincided with the removal efficiency. Electrochemical ammonia removal was carried out using two external electrical currents, 40 and 80 mA. Results showed that ECS2 gave the highest ammonia removal efficiency of 95.08% at 80 mA in case of 500 ppm, and the maximum for recovery was 80% when 1000 ppm was tested at 80 mA along with an increase in pH in the cathode chamber. Furthermore, ECS2 consumed less energy than ECS1 for ammonia recovery. ECS2 efficiently treated slaughterhouse wastewater reaching almost 100% ammonia removal; however, the maximum recovery of 44.7% occurred after 6 h, but consuming less energy than ECS1. It was evidenced that using an anode coated with nanographene oxide provided dual benefits of quickness and effective ammonia removal and/or recovery and provisioning energy requirements.
AI summary
72% confidenceThis study evaluated microbial fuel cells (MFCs) and electrochemical systems (ECS) for ammonia removal and recovery from slaughterhouse wastewater at 500–1500 ppm initial concentrations. A graphite anode coated with nanographene oxide (from pomegranate peels) outperformed uncoated controls, especially at high ammonia levels. MFC systems achieved 83–99% removal with no external power; ECS systems achieved 21–100% removal at 40–80 mA applied current, consuming 0.32–3.13 kWh kg⁻¹ N, substantially lower than nitrification–denitrification or air stripping.
Key insights
Trade-off MFC1 (uncoated) achieved 96.2% ammonia removal at 500 ppm in 13 days, but removal dropped to 85.6% at 1500 ppm; MFC2 (coated) showed inverse behavior: 83.4% at 500 ppm but 99.4% at 1500 ppm in 25 days.
So what. Electrode coating with nanographene oxide shifts the operating window toward high-ammonia wastewaters; uncoated electrodes are better only for dilute feeds below 500 ppm.
Threshold ECS2 at 80 mA achieved 80% ammonia recovery efficiency at 1000 ppm initial concentration, while ECS1 achieved only 45.84% under identical conditions.
So what. Applied current of 80 mA is necessary to unlock high recovery efficiency in coated systems; 40 mA is insufficient for concentrated feeds.
Mechanism Cathode pH rose from 7–8 to 11–13 during ECS operation, converting NH4+ to NH3 for volatilization and recovery; anode pH dropped to 2–3 in ECS2, indicating complete ammonium depletion.
So what. Monitor anode pH drop as a real-time indicator of ammonia depletion; high cathode pH (>11) is required for recovery but limits downstream use of the recovered product.
Performance Energy consumption for ECS2 ammonia recovery was 2.272 kWh kg⁻¹ at 500 ppm and 3.804 kWh kg⁻¹ at 1000 ppm (80 mA, 6 h), compared to 5.937 and 9.081 kWh kg⁻¹ for ECS1 under the same conditions.
So what. Nanographene oxide coating reduces energy demand by 62–58% across the tested ammonia range; prioritize coated electrodes for energy-constrained applications.
Performance Real slaughterhouse wastewater (667.9 ppm initial ammonia) achieved 100% removal and 44.7% recovery in ECS2 at 40 mA in 6 h, but only 80% removal and 35.9% recovery in ECS1.
So what. Coated systems maintain performance on real wastewater; uncoated systems degrade significantly, suggesting fouling or inhibition by co-contaminants (proteins, lipids) in slaughterhouse effluent.
Contradictions1
Tensions the paper itself points to. Each side quotes the passage it comes from.
Within the paper Ammonia removal efficiency in MFC1 decreases with increasing initial ammonia concentration, but MFC2 shows the opposite trend.
One sideMFC1 removal: 96.2% at 500 ppm, 88.5% at 1000 ppm, 85.6% at 1500 ppm
“At low initial ammonia concentration (500 ppm), ammonia removal efficiency was higher in MFC1 than MFC2 (96% and 83%; respectively). By contrast, at higher ammonia concentrations (1000 and 1500 ppm), removal efficiency using MFC1 was 88.5% ”
Other sideMFC2 removal: 83.4% at 500 ppm, 94.4% at 1000 ppm, 99.4% at 1500 ppm
“MFC 2 was not affected by high concentration of ammonia due to the larger electrode surface area (682 m⁻² g −1) and pore size (122 nm), which allows ammonia adsorption on electrode surface and thus decreases the inhibitory effect of the hig”
Authors’ reading. Authors attribute the inversion to electrode surface area and pore size in the coating, which enables ammonia adsorption and buffers against inhibition at high concentrations. MFC1 lacks this capacity and is inhibited by high ammonia. This is a mechanistic explanation, not a true contradiction.
Opportunity areas6
Specific gaps in this paper, with an experiment that would close each.
High No measurement of nitrite (NO2⁻) or nitrous oxide (N2O) accumulation in either MFC or ECS systems despite nitrogen cycling occurring in the anode chamber.
Ammonia is oxidized to nitrogen oxides in the anode; the paper does not report whether NO2⁻ or N2O accumulate, which would indicate incomplete oxidation or denitrification side-reactions. This is critical for understanding nitrogen mass balance and environmental impact.
Try. Measure NO2⁻, NO3⁻, and N2O in anode and cathode chambers at 500, 1000, 1500 ppm initial ammonia over the full treatment period; use ion chromatography and gas chromatography.
High No systematic variation of applied current density (mA cm⁻²) or cathode potential (V vs. Ag/AgCl) in ECS experiments; only two fixed currents (40 and 80 mA) tested.
Current density and cathode potential are known to control ammonia recovery efficiency and N2O selectivity in electrochemical systems. The paper applies absolute current without normalizing to electrode area, making it impossible to compare with other studies or scale up.
Try. Vary current density from 5 to 50 mA cm⁻² at fixed cathode potentials (−0.5 to −1.2 V vs. Ag/AgCl); measure ammonia removal, recovery, and N2O production.
Medium No investigation of hydraulic retention time (HRT) or residence time effects; ECS experiments run for only 6 h with fixed flow rate (18 mL min⁻¹) and MFC experiments run to completion (13–25 days) without intermediate time-course data.
HRT is a critical operating parameter in bioelectrochemical systems. The paper does not explore whether shorter or longer residence times improve recovery efficiency or reduce energy consumption.
Try. Vary HRT from 2 to 24 h in ECS by adjusting flow rate; measure ammonia removal, recovery, and energy consumption as a function of HRT at fixed current density.
Medium No measurement of dissolved oxygen (DO) in anode or cathode chambers; anaerobic conditions assumed but not verified.
Oxygen ingress into the anode chamber would suppress exoelectrogenic bacteria and shift ammonia oxidation pathways. DO in the cathode affects the cathode reaction and pH dynamics.
Try. Monitor DO continuously in both chambers using oxygen probes; correlate DO with ammonia removal rate and current generation in MFC systems.
Medium No characterization of the microbial community in MFC anode biofilm; mechanism of ammonia oxidation and transport not confirmed.
The paper assumes exoelectrogenic bacteria oxidize organic matter and that ammonia is a byproduct, but does not identify the organisms or confirm the metabolic pathway. Nitrifying bacteria may also be present.
Try. 16S rRNA gene sequencing of anode biofilm at 500, 1000, 1500 ppm ammonia; correlate community composition with ammonia removal rate and current generation.
Medium Recovered ammonium sulfate product contaminated with trivalent chromium (from potassium dichromate catholyte) and unsuitable for food crops; no alternative catholyte tested.
The paper acknowledges the chromium contamination and restricts use to non-edible plants, but does not explore alternative electron acceptors (e.g., oxygen, permanganate, ferricyanide) that would yield a clean product.
Try. Replace potassium dichromate with dissolved oxygen or ferricyanide as the cathode electron acceptor; measure ammonia recovery efficiency and product purity.
Generated by MESSAI extraction pipeline · review against source PDF
Extracted values
Every value pulled from the paper, with its source, so each number can be checked against the text.
n = 106 extracted values
Select a citation to see the quote, page and confidence behind a value.
82 of 106 extracted rows modelable
- 4 not canonicalised (no canonical slug)
- 16 no SI value
- 4 contradicts other papers
| Parameter | Value | Unit | Confidence | Source | Notes | Modelable |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Substrate | wastewater | — | 70% | extracted | Excluded: no SI value | |
| Electrode material | graphite | — | 50% | extracted | Excluded: not canonicalised (no canonical slug) | |
| Average Pore Size | 122 | nm | 0% | extracted | "and pore size (122 nm)" | Modelable |
| time to reach maximum ammonia removal | 13 | d | 0% | extracted | "at low initial ammonia concentration 500 ppm, lower time was needed (13 days)" · time_since_start_h=312 | Excluded: not canonicalised (no canonical slug) |
| time to reach maximum ammonia removal | 25 | d | 0% | extracted | "while at high concentration (1500 ppm) reached 25 days to achieve maximum ammoni…" · time_since_start_h=600 | Excluded: not canonicalised (no canonical slug) |
| Peak Current | 40 | mA | 0% | extracted | "in the presence of resistance of 10 Ω and current of 40 mA." | Modelable |
| Ammonium-N Removed | 83.4 | % | 0% | extracted | "Table 1 ... MFC2 ... Ammonia removal% 83.4" · replicates_n=3, time_since_start_h=312 | Modelable |
| Substrate Concentration | 500 | ppm | 0% | extracted | "ammonia at various initial ammonia concentrations (500 ppm, 1000 ppm, and 1500 p…" · replicates_n=3 | Modelable |
| Influent Temperature | 37 | °C | 0% | extracted | "Temperature was adjusted to 37 ± 2 °C." · T=37°C | Modelable |
| Substrate Concentration | 1,000 | ppm | 0% | extracted | "Different initial ammonia concentrations (500 ppm, 1000 ppm, and 1500 ppm) were …" · replicates_n=2 | Modelable |
| Ammonium-N Removed | 94.4 | % | 0% | extracted | "lower than that using MFC2 (94.4% and 99.4%; respectively)" | Modelable |
| Chemical Oxygen Demand (COD) Removal | 88.3 | % | 0% | extracted | "Table 1 ... MFC2 ... COD removal% 88.28" · replicates_n=3, time_since_start_h=312 | Modelable |
| Chemical Oxygen Demand (COD) Removal | 94.7 | % | 0% | extracted | "Table 1 ... MFC2 ... COD removal% 94.65" · replicates_n=3, time_since_start_h=456 | Modelable |
| Ammonia Recovery | 35.9 | % | 0% | extracted | "The NH3/NH4+ recovery values for ECS1 and ECS2 are 35.9% and 44.7%, respectively…" | Modelable |
| Substrate Concentration | 500 | ppm | 0% | extracted | "Different initial ammonia concentrations (500 ppm, 1000 ppm, and 1500 ppm) were …" · replicates_n=2 | Modelable |
| Ammonium-N Removed | 99.4 | % | 0% | extracted | "MFC2 gave maximum removal efficiency of 94.4% and 99.4% for 1000 and 1500 ppm af…" · replicates_n=3, time_since_start_h=600 | Modelable |
| pH Level | 7.84 | — | 0% | extracted | "Table 2 ... pH level ECS1 ... Feeding solution 7.84" · steady_state | Modelable |
| Chemical Oxygen Demand (COD) Removal | 86 | % | 0% | extracted | "in the case of MFC 1, a consistent COD% removal regardless of the initial ammoni…" | Modelable |
| pH Level | 11.7 | — | 0% | extracted | "Table 2 ... pH level ECS1 ... Recovery solution 11.67" · steady_state | Modelable |
| Ammonium-N Removed | 56.2 | % | 0% | extracted | "The maximal ammonia removal and recovery efficiency of ECS2 was of 56.2% and 54.…" | Modelable |
| Ammonia Recovery | 80 | % | 0% | extracted | "the maximum recovery efficiency of ECS2 was better than ECS1 reaching 80% at 80 …" · replicates_n=2 | Modelable |
| Ammonium-N Removed | 88.5 | % | 0% | extracted | "at higher ammonia concentrations (1000 and 1500 ppm), removal efficiency using M…" | Modelable |
| Ammonium-N Removed | 84.6 | % | 0% | extracted | "maximum ammonia removal efficiency for ECS1 was 84.6% at 40 mA" · replicates_n=2 | Modelable |
| Ammonium-N Removed | 99.4 | % | 0% | extracted | "lower than that using MFC2 (94.4% and 99.4%; respectively)" | Modelable |
| External Load | 10 | Ω | 0% | extracted | "voltage across the 10 Ω external resistor." · external_resistance_ohm=10 | Modelable |
Literature priors
Against the literature
The author’s reported value (▼) sits on top of the literature distribution from MESS-Parameters. Values outside the band are flagged as outliers.
Methodology
What was the system and how was it run
Methodology
Methodology
Two-chamber MFC and ECS systems were operated in parallel with non-coated and nanographene oxide-coated graphite plate anodes. MFC systems used sodium acetate (1 g L⁻¹) as electron donor and potassium dichromate (100 mM in 250 mM H₂SO₄) as cathode electrolyte; ammonia was monitored daily by Nessler method over 13–25 days. ECS systems applied constant external current (40 or 80 mA) for 6 h with synthetic or real slaughterhouse wastewater (500–1500 ppm or 667.9 ppm initial ammonia); ammonia, pH, and voltage were measured hourly. Energy consumption was calculated as W = I × V integrated over time, and specific energy (kWh kg⁻¹ NH₃-N) was derived from recovery efficiency and power input.
Electrode specifications
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| materials | ["graphite","graphene"] |
Performance metrics
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| coulombic efficiency | 95.08 |
| citation count | 2 |
Operational parameters
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| substrate | ["wastewater"] |
Operating conditions
6 runs extracted| Run | T°C | pHan | pHcat | Substrate | [S]mg/L | HRTh | Mode | R_extΩ | V_appV | Inoculum |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| v2-23c98577e2ec43a7 | — | — | — | sodium acetate | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| v2-3aa9ff9e2ec4e57c | — | — | — | — | — | — | steady_state | — | — | — |
| v2-979cf0b9e7f42d06 | — | — | — | — | — | — | steady_state | — | — | — |
| v2-d4461c4f1e900e3f | 37 | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| v2-f586e9af22985397 | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| v2-ff5348c538bb29e6 | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | 10 | — | — |
Outcomes
What was measured and what worked
Key takeaways
Coulombic efficiency
electrochemistry95.08percent
Pipeline
Raw extractions, artifacts, quality signal
Extraction quality
honesty signalCalibrate your trust in the extracted content against these signals — they're how the pipeline rated its own output for this paper.
Parameter completeness
50%
Fraction of expected parameters extracted
Data completeness
60%
Overall extraction coverage across fields
AI confidence
72%
Model self-reported confidence
Mean parameter confidence
1%
Average confidence across PaperParameter rows surfaced above
review against source PDF before citing · scores 0–1
Chart explorer
Move the inputs this paper used and see how the predicted outcome shifts.
Explore model
The reactor in 3D, with flow you can switch on and off.
AI insights
Contradictions, gaps and opportunities found by comparing this paper with the corpus.
Compare similar papers
The nearest papers by system, materials and organisms, with their outcomes side by side.
Source PDF
The paper as published.
Representative model, generic MFC
Tap to interactRepresentative model, generic MFC
Representative MFC — matched on the paper’s system type only, not its reactor or geometry.
In this record
Organisms, parameters and materials this paper reports. Each links to its page.
Parameters · 1
Keywords
- Wastewater
- Industrial and production engineering
- Ammonia
- Electrochemistry
- Waste management
- Ammonia production
Cite
Afaf Abdel Razik Mohamed, Ali El-Dissouky Ali, Mohamed Salah El-Din Hassouna et al. (2025). Efficacy of bioelectrochemical and electrochemical systems in ammonia recovery from slaughterhouse wastewater. Applied Water Science. https://doi.org/10.1007/s13201-024-02355-4
- Journal
- Applied Water Science
Open in lab for full controls, parameter editing, and template overlays.
Open in lab