Leibniz-HKI Jena · Microbial electrosynthesis · draft 6 Nov 2026
Can a community description be paired with an MES outcome, paper by paper?
Microbial electrosynthesis papers describe their cathode communities and report their rates, but rarely in a form that lets the two be read together across studies. MESSAI holds the literature and a schema that already has room for community rows. This page measures the gap and proposes what to build with the HKI group.
- Community rows with provenanceDominant genera, abundance, compartment and time point, extracted for the community papers in scope.
- Acetogen records that answer MES questionsOxygen-exposure tolerance and the evidence for inward electron transfer, on the catalog records of the acetogens.
- Three reporting itemsAccession, sampling compartment, time point: the minimum that makes a community comparable.
The question
Can a microbial community description be paired with a measured MES outcome, paper by paper, across the literature?
Today, for 3 of 420 papers in the electrosynthesis scope: their abstract mentions a community method, MESSAI holds organism rows for them, and it holds a measured outcome row.
The scope is 420 live papers on microbial electrosynthesis. “Community” means the abstract mentions 16S, metagenomics, amplicon sequencing, metatranscriptomics, a microbial community or community composition: a mention, not proof that sequence data exists.
| Papers in the electrosynthesis scope | Papers |
|---|---|
| All live papers in scope | 420 |
| Abstract mentions a community | 41 |
| … with a measured MES outcome row | 17 |
| … with organism rows (PaperMicrobe) | 5 |
| … with organism rows and an outcome | 3 |
| … with a sequence accession in the abstract | 0 |
An outcome row is a live extracted value for one of: Acetate production rate, Faradaic efficiency, Faradaic efficiency CO₂, Acetate titre, Acetate concentration, Methane production rate, Butyrate production rate, Formic acid production rate, Current density, Current density areal, Current density volumetric. A paper that reports both may describe its community and its rate for different runs; this is co-reporting, not a pairing of run with run.
What already exists
The schema is ready for community rows; the rows are not filled.
Each organism a paper names is a row of PaperMicrobe, with the columns below. A row can already carry an abundance, a rank and a dominance flag, and point at the run (ConditionSet) it was measured in.
| Column | Holds |
|---|---|
| canonicalId | The organism’s slug in the microbe catalog, or empty when unresolved |
| asReported | The name as the paper writes it |
| rank | Taxonomic rank: genus, species, strain, OTU or ASV |
| relativeAbundancePct | Relative abundance, in per cent |
| isDominant | Whether the paper calls it dominant |
| conditionSetId | The run (condition set) the row belongs to |
Corpus-wide, 1,724 organism rows on 1,110 live papers; 100 of those rows are on electrosynthesis papers.
The microbe catalog is the open mess-microbes seed: 28 organisms, among them the acetogens and methanogens of MES. Next to it sit 4 curated omics-study pointers (proteomics, transcriptomics) and 0 metagenomic analyses.
Organisms named in electrosynthesis papers
| Organism | Rows | Papers |
|---|---|---|
| Named but not resolved to the catalog | 36 | 16 |
| Shewanella oneidensis MR-1 | 23 | 19 |
| Sporomusa ovata | 14 | 14 |
| Clostridium ljungdahlii | 6 | 6 |
| Geobacter sulfurreducens PCA | 6 | 5 |
| Methanococcus maripaludis S2 | 4 | 4 |
| Acetobacterium woodii | 3 | 3 |
| Moorella thermoacetica | 2 | 2 |
| Clostridium autoethanogenum DSM 10061 | 2 | 2 |
| Pseudomonas aeruginosa PA14 | 2 | 2 |
| Rhodopseudomonas palustris DX-1 | 1 | 1 |
| Sporomusa sphaeroides | 1 | 1 |
Anode organisms (Shewanella, Geobacter) appear because the scope includes papers that report an outcome such as faradaic efficiency, not only cathodic MES.
Which taxa the abstracts name
| Taxonfirst match wins | Papers, corpus-wide | In the electrosynthesis scope | With an outcome row |
|---|---|---|---|
| Methanogens (any genus) | 306 | 31 | 36 |
| Acetobacterium | 26 | 17 | 12 |
| Sporomusa | 18 | 17 | 7 |
| Clostridium ljungdahlii | 7 | 4 | 1 |
| Moorella | 4 | 2 | 1 |
| Eubacterium limosum | 1 | 0 | 1 |
| Clostridium autoethanogenum | 1 | 1 | 1 |
Each abstract counts once, for the first taxon it matches in the order the query tests them; “with an outcome row” is counted over all papers that mention the taxon, not only those in scope.
The three gaps
What stands between a community mention and a community row that can be compared with another study’s.
No accessions
0 of 41 community papers in scope carry a 16S or metagenome accession (PRJNA, PRJEB, SRR, …) in the abstract; corpus-wide, 1 of 1,068. Accessions in the full text are not counted, so this is a lower bound, but without one the community cannot be re-analysed.
No abundances
14 of 1,724 organism rows carry a relative abundance, and none of the 1,068 community papers corpus-wide has one. A list of names says who was there, not how much of the community they were.
Unresolved names
780 of 1,724 organism rows name an organism that is not resolved to the catalog: a genus without a species, a clone label, a spelling the resolver does not know. Unresolved, the same organism counts as several.
What MESSAI would do
Three pieces of work, each checked against the HKI group before it is called done.
(a) Extract community rows for the 41 papers
ProposedFor each community paper in scope: the dominant genera, their relative abundance where the paper gives one, the compartment (cathode biofilm or planktonic) and the time point, each landing in
PaperMicrobewith its source sentence, table or figure and the extractor version. Rows are tied to the run they were measured in, so a community can be read next to that run’s rate.(b) Fill in the acetogen records
ProposedThe catalog schema already has an oxygen-exposure tolerance field; 0 of the 5 acetogen records fill it. 4 of the 5 already state a cathode electron-uptake mechanism, without the evidence beside it. We would add the tolerance, and the papers behind each uptake classification (direct transfer, via H₂, via formate), so that a contested claim is visible as contested.
(c) Propose three reporting items for MES papers
ProposedFor every community an MES paper describes: the sequence accession, the sampling compartment and the time point. These would go to the reporting standard on /collab/gath later, once the HKI group has said they are the right ones, not now.
- Sequence accession (16S amplicon or metagenome, in a public archive)
- Sampling compartment (cathode biofilm, planktonic, or both)
- Time point (days after inoculation or after the potential was applied)
What we ask of the HKI group
- Defined-culture and mixed-community MES runs we could check the extracted rows of (a) against: a few runs where the community and the rate are both known.
- A review of (b): whether the oxygen tolerances and the inward-transfer evidence we attach to Sporomusa, Clostridium ljungdahlii, Acetobacterium woodii and Moorella are the ones her group would cite.
- Whether the three reporting items of (c) are the right ones, and what a fourth would be if one is missing.
Papers
This page lists no papers yet: the snapshot holds counts, not titles.
Papers whose author list contains “Rosenbaum”: 23 live papers, 16 with extracted values, 14 with organism rows. The match is on the surname, so name variants are missed and another author of the same name would count.
Sara Al Sbei’s one corpus paper, “The oxygen dilemma” (Frontiers in Microbiology, 2022, with Rosenbaum and Harnisch), is a Perspective: it reports no values of its own, and the corpus records none.
A list of the 41 community papers in scope, by DOI and title, needs the measuring query to emit them and a re-run on staging; it will be added here when that is done.
Open questions for the HKI group
- Is “community” the right abstract predicate? It catches 16S, metagenomics, amplicons and the words “microbial community”; it misses defined co-cultures and papers that sequence but do not say so in the abstract.
- Should methanogens be counted apart from acetogens? In a mixed cathode they compete for the same electrons; in the counts above they are one bucket of their own.
- Which headline is honest: 3 of 420 (papers in scope with a community, organism rows and an outcome) or 17 of 41 (community papers with an outcome)?
- Which papers should be read first? The group’s own MES papers, or the community papers with an outcome row?