Forschungsdaten – Titel und Zusammenfassungen von Publikationen, extrahierte Daten und Katalogeinträge – erscheinen in ihrer Originalsprache Englisch.

Forschung

Publikation · MFC

The Role of Carbon to Nitrogen Ratio on the Performance of Denitrifying Biocathodes for Decentralized Wastewater Treatment

01

Zusammenfassung

Was die Publikation berichtet, in ihren eigenen Worten.

Interaktives 3D-ModellKI-angereichert· 82 %

Zusammenfassung

Bioelectrochemical systems with denitrifying biocathodes have been of interest for the removal of nitrate in decentralized wastewater treatment applications. Only a few studies have directly focused on this application, but the removal rates have been very low. This study evaluated the operational parameters that affect the nitrate removal of two-chambered microbial fuel cells (MFCs) with a biocathode, particularly, the carbon to nitrogen ratio (C:N) and proton diffusivity across electrode chambers. The results show that proton diffusion across a proton exchange membrane is not a limiting step in nitrogen removal performance. At C:N ratios of 4 and 8, biocathodes with a continuously supplied carbon source at the anode were able to achieve complete nitrogen removal at a rate of 0.97 ± 0.21 and 1.15 ± 0.13 mg N L⁻¹ d⁻¹, respectively. However, as the C:N ratio increased from 4, 8, 16, and 32, the electrode potentials decreased accordingly. Ratio 4 C:N had a cathodic reduction potential of +66.1 ± 5.3 mV vs. SHE and dropped to −78.6 ± 9.8 mV vs. SHE at 32 C:N. The cathode electrode potential can be controlled by way of the carbon concentrations at the anode, which can have major indirect implications on the evolution of cathodic microbial communities that have preference to particular ranges of reduction potentials. The cathodic biofilms in this study were dominated by the phyla Proteobacteria, Acidobacteria, Bacteroidetes and Nitrospirae, which are known to have key denitrifying microorganisms. The genus Stenotrophomonas was found in abundance within the attached cathode biofilm and to a lesser extent in the suspended biomass. Vibrio, Acidobacteria_Gp4, Nitrosomonas, and Candidatus Competibacter were also cultivated in both the suspended and attached biomass. Nitrospira was only found in the attached biofilm. Regardless of operational scheme, nitrogen removal was improved at low C:N ratios, with 8 C:N having the best performance overall. This indicates that higher C:N ratios than were previously explored (>4 C:N) provide sufficient coulombs to facilitate denitrification at the cathode even while the anodic CEs remain low. Reactor design modifications should be considered to fully support robust denitrifying communities, enhancing the overall nitrogen removal for decentralized wastewater treatment applications.

KI-Zusammenfassung

82 % Konfidenz

Zentrale Erkenntnisse

  • Mechanismus Cathode potential can be passively controlled by varying anode carbon concentration: increasing C:N from 4 to 32 decreased cathode potential by 144.7 mV (from +66.1 to −78.6 mV vs. SHE).

    Was heißt das. Operators can tune cathode potential without a potentiostat by adjusting anode substrate loading, enabling potential-dependent community selection in decentralized systems without external power.

  • Schwellenwert Nitrogen removal rate plateaued at C:N 8 (1.15 ± 0.13 mg N L⁻¹ d⁻¹) under continuous anode feed; higher C:N ratios (16, 32) did not improve removal despite higher coulomb availability.

    Was heißt das. Operating above C:N 8 wastes anode substrate without improving denitrification; C:N 8 is the practical optimum for this system geometry and inoculum.

  • Mechanismus Proton transfer across the PEM was not rate-limiting; transfer rate scaled linearly with membrane area (3.6× faster with 4× larger membrane) and was 10× faster under +1 V applied voltage.

    Was heißt das. Membrane size and proton availability are not the primary bottleneck for denitrification in this system; focus optimization on cathode biofilm activity and electron transfer instead.

  • Zielkonflikt Anodic coulombic efficiency remained low (16.5–32.7%) even with continuous carbon feed, suggesting significant carbon diversion to non-electrochemical pathways (likely methanogenesis).

    Was heißt das. Low anode CE limits electron availability to the cathode; reactor design should suppress methanogenesis or recover methane to improve overall nitrogen removal efficiency.

  • Mechanismus Stenotrophomonas maltophilia dominated the attached biofilm (26.2% relative abundance) and is a facultative anaerobe capable of electrode respiration and anaerobic nitrate reduction.

    Was heißt das. This organism is a key functional player; enrichment strategies targeting Stenotrophomonas or similar facultative electroactive denitrifiers could improve performance in decentralized systems.

Widersprüche2

Nur Konflikte, die die Publikation selbst zeigt, jeweils am Text geprüft.

  • Innerhalb der Publikation Batch operation showed no significant difference in nitrogen removal across C:N ratios, but continuous operation showed clear improvement at low C:N.

    Eine Seite

    Batch phase: 'Analysis of these results revealed that there was no statistically significant difference (p > 0.05) in nitrogen removal rate means across the different starting C:N ratios' with rates of 4.21, 9.97, 2.1, and 2.03 mg N L⁻¹ d⁻¹ for C:N 4, 8, 16, 32.

    “Analysis of these results revealed that there was no statistically significant difference (p > 0.05) in nitrogen removal rate means across the different starting C:N ratios.”
    Andere Seite

    Continuous phase: 'With a continuous flow anode, C:N ratios of 4 and 8 observed near complete removal of nitrogen within 18 days, with removal rates of 0.97 ± 0.21 and 1.15 ± 0.13 mg N L⁻¹ d⁻¹, respectively. The nitrogen removal performance decreased as the C:N ratio increased.'

    “The nitrogen removal performance decreased as the C:N ratio increased.”

    Einordnung der Autoren. The authors attribute this to endogenous decay and electron limitation in batch mode: 'the nitrogen removal rate at the cathode was vastly slower than the rate of organic source at the anode' and 'nitrogen concentrations at the cathode increased slightly for two of the replicate MFCs after all the carbon source was depleted at the anode at day 3.' Continuous feed prevents electron starvation, revealing the true C:N dependence.

  • Innerhalb der Publikation High anode carbon removal (92.8–94.2%) coexists with low anodic coulombic efficiency (19.9–32.7%), suggesting a mechanistic disconnect.

    Eine Seite

    Carbon removal: 'the anode carbon removal performance across the respective replicates was 90.9 ± 23.2%, 94.2 ± 5.7%, 92.8 ± 26.8%, and 93.9 ± 24.7% for C:N ratios 4, 8, 16, and 32, respectively.'

    “the anode carbon removal performance across the respective replicates was 90.9 ± 23.2%, 94.2 ± 5.7%, 92.8 ± 26.8%, and 93.9 ± 24.7%”
    Andere Seite

    Coulombic efficiency: 'the anodic CEs also improved with a constant carbon flux, observing values of 32.7 ± 0.15%, 19.9 ± 0.03%, 20.7 ± 0.06%, and 25.6 ± 0.06% for C:N ratios 4, 8, 16, and 32, respectively.'

    “the anodic CEs also improved with a constant carbon flux, observing values of 32.7 ± 0.15%, 19.9 ± 0.03%, 20.7 ± 0.06%, and 25.6 ± 0.06%”

    Einordnung der Autoren. The authors explain: 'It is speculated that the combination of low anodic CE and high COD removal suggest that organic matter was oxidized by microorganisms that did not utilize the anode as an electron acceptor. Carbon diversion to methane production is likely but was not quantified.' This is a trade-off, not a true contradiction, but reveals a design flaw in the anode compartment.

Ansatzpunkte6

Konkrete Lücken in dieser Publikation, jeweils mit einem Experiment, das sie schließen würde.

  • Hoch Quantify methane production from the anode to determine the fraction of carbon diverted to methanogenesis versus electrochemical oxidation.

    High COD removal (92.8–94.2%) paired with low anodic CE (19.9–32.7%) strongly suggests methanogenesis, but the paper states 'Carbon diversion to methane production is likely but was not quantified.' This is critical for understanding true electron availability to the cathode.

    Versuch. Measure biogas composition (CH₄, CO₂) from anode headspace during continuous feed operation at each C:N ratio; correlate to CE deficit.

  • Mittel Test C:N ratios between 8 and 16 to identify the precise threshold where nitrogen removal begins to decline.

    The paper tests C:N 4, 8, 16, 32 but shows best performance at 8 and degradation at 16. The transition zone is not characterized, limiting practical optimization.

    Versuch. Operate continuous anode at C:N 8, 10, 12, 14, 16 with same 18-day cathode cycle; measure nitrogen removal rate and cathode potential.

  • Hoch Investigate whether the decrease in nitrogen removal at high C:N (16, 32) is due to cathode potential becoming too negative (unfavorable for denitrifiers) or to insufficient proton availability.

    Cathode potential drops to −104 to −78.6 mV vs. SHE at C:N 16–32, but the paper shows proton transfer is not limiting. The mechanism behind performance loss at high C:N is unclear.

    Versuch. Operate reactors at C:N 16 and 32 with externally poised cathode potentials (e.g., −50, −100, −150 mV vs. SHE) to decouple potential effects from carbon availability effects.

  • Mittel Characterize the microbial community composition at the anode to explain the low coulombic efficiency and identify organisms responsible for methanogenesis.

    The paper sequenced only the cathode biofilm and suspended biomass. Anode community composition was not explored, yet the anode is the source of the electron limitation problem.

    Versuch. 16S rRNA sequencing of anode biofilm and suspended biomass from Phase II continuous feed reactors at each C:N ratio.

  • Mittel Test the effect of cathode pH on nitrogen removal rate and N₂O accumulation across the C:N range.

    The paper states 'The pH of the cathode was measured and adjusted with HCl to maintain levels below pH 8' but does not report actual pH values or test pH as a variable. Cathode pH is known to affect denitrification pathway selection and N₂O production.

    Versuch. Operate continuous feed reactors at C:N 4, 8, 16 with cathode pH maintained at 6.5, 7.0, 7.5, 8.0; measure NO₃⁻, NO₂⁻, N₂O, and N₂ removal.

  • Mittel Measure nitrite and N₂O accumulation during nitrogen removal to assess whether incomplete denitrification occurs at high C:N ratios.

    The paper reports total nitrogen (TN) removal and NO₃⁻ removal but does not explicitly report NO₂⁻ or N₂O concentrations during the continuous feed phase. Incomplete denitrification could explain the performance loss at high C:N.

    Versuch. During Phase II continuous feed, measure NO₃⁻, NO₂⁻, and N₂O concentrations daily for all C:N ratios; calculate denitrification pathway distribution.

Erstellt von der MESSAI-Extraktionspipeline · mit dem Quell-PDF abgleichen

02

Extrahierte Werte

Jeder aus der Publikation entnommene Wert mit seiner Quelle, damit sich jede Zahl am Text prüfen lässt.

n = 23 extrahierte Werte

Wählen Sie eine Quellenangabe, um Zitat, Seite und Konfidenz hinter einem Wert zu sehen.

0 von 23 extrahierten Zeilen modellierbar

  • 12 nicht kanonisiert (kein kanonischer Slug)
  • 11 kein SI-Wert
ParameterWertEinheitKonfidenzQuelleAnmerkungenModellierbar
Cathodic coulombic efficiency41,3%90 %
extrahiert
"the average cathodic CEs between replicates remained high at low C:N ratios (38.…" · substrate=sodium acetateAusgeschlossen: nicht kanonisiert (kein kanonischer Slug)
Anodic coulombic efficiency16,5%90 %
extrahiert
"the anodic CEs remained low and below 20%, with 8 C:N showing the highest averag…" · substrate=sodium acetateAusgeschlossen: nicht kanonisiert (kein kanonischer Slug)
Cathodic coulombic efficiency38%90 %
extrahiert
"the average cathodic CEs between replicates remained high at low C:N ratios (38.…" · substrate=sodium acetateAusgeschlossen: nicht kanonisiert (kein kanonischer Slug)
Anodic coulombic efficiency20,7%90 %
extrahiert
"The anodic CEs also improved with a constant carbon flux, observing values of 32…" · substrate=sodium acetate, HRT=28.8hAusgeschlossen: nicht kanonisiert (kein kanonischer Slug)
Anodic coulombic efficiency13,5%90 %
extrahiert
"the anodic CEs remained low and below 20%, with 8 C:N showing the highest averag…" · substrate=sodium acetateAusgeschlossen: nicht kanonisiert (kein kanonischer Slug)
Anodic coulombic efficiency32,7%90 %
extrahiert
"The anodic CEs also improved with a constant carbon flux, observing values of 32…" · substrate=sodium acetate, HRT=28.8hAusgeschlossen: nicht kanonisiert (kein kanonischer Slug)
Anodic coulombic efficiency19,9%90 %
extrahiert
"The anodic CEs also improved with a constant carbon flux, observing values of 32…" · substrate=sodium acetate, HRT=28.8hAusgeschlossen: nicht kanonisiert (kein kanonischer Slug)
Anodic coulombic efficiency25,6%90 %
extrahiert
"The anodic CEs also improved with a constant carbon flux, observing values of 32…" · substrate=sodium acetate, HRT=28.8hAusgeschlossen: nicht kanonisiert (kein kanonischer Slug)
Cathode Potential-104mV vs. SHE90 %
extrahiert
"The average potentials during the cycles for ratios 4, 8, 16, and 32 were 66.1 ±…" · substrate=sodium acetate, HRT=28.8hAusgeschlossen: kein SI-Wert
Cathode Potential66,1mV vs. SHE90 %
extrahiert
"The average potentials during the cycles for ratios 4, 8, 16, and 32 were 66.1 ±…" · substrate=sodium acetate, HRT=28.8hAusgeschlossen: kein SI-Wert
Cathode Potential-78,6mV vs. SHE90 %
extrahiert
"The average potentials during the cycles for ratios 4, 8, 16, and 32 were 66.1 ±…" · substrate=sodium acetate, HRT=28.8hAusgeschlossen: kein SI-Wert
Anode carbon removal92,8%90 %
extrahiert
"On average, the anode carbon removal performance across the respective replicate…" · substrate=sodium acetate, HRT=28.8hAusgeschlossen: nicht kanonisiert (kein kanonischer Slug)
Anode carbon removal90,9%90 %
extrahiert
"On average, the anode carbon removal performance across the respective replicate…" · substrate=sodium acetate, HRT=28.8hAusgeschlossen: nicht kanonisiert (kein kanonischer Slug)
Anode carbon removal93,9%90 %
extrahiert
"On average, the anode carbon removal performance across the respective replicate…" · substrate=sodium acetate, HRT=28.8hAusgeschlossen: nicht kanonisiert (kein kanonischer Slug)
Anode carbon removal94,2%90 %
extrahiert
"On average, the anode carbon removal performance across the respective replicate…" · substrate=sodium acetate, HRT=28.8hAusgeschlossen: nicht kanonisiert (kein kanonischer Slug)
Cathode Potential-17,7mV vs. SHE90 %
extrahiert
"The average potentials during the cycles for ratios 4, 8, 16, and 32 were 66.1 ±…" · substrate=sodium acetate, HRT=28.8hAusgeschlossen: kein SI-Wert
Nitrogen Removal4,21mg N L⁻¹ d⁻¹90 %
extrahiert
"The average removal rates of nitrogen under these conditions were 4.21 ± 2.28, 9…" · substrate=sodium acetateAusgeschlossen: kein SI-Wert
Nitrogen Removal9,97mg N L⁻¹ d⁻¹90 %
extrahiert
"The average removal rates of nitrogen under these conditions were 4.21 ± 2.28, 9…" · substrate=sodium acetateAusgeschlossen: kein SI-Wert
Nitrogen Removal2,03mg N L⁻¹ d⁻¹90 %
extrahiert
"The average removal rates of nitrogen under these conditions were 4.21 ± 2.28, 9…" · substrate=sodium acetateAusgeschlossen: kein SI-Wert
Nitrogen Removal2,1mg N L⁻¹ d⁻¹90 %
extrahiert
"The average removal rates of nitrogen under these conditions were 4.21 ± 2.28, 9…" · substrate=sodium acetateAusgeschlossen: kein SI-Wert
Nitrogen Removal0,88mg N L⁻¹ d⁻¹90 %
extrahiert
"The removal rates bounced back slightly by the end of the study, with PEM size 4…" · substrate=sodium acetateAusgeschlossen: kein SI-Wert
Nitrogen Removal1,15mg N L⁻¹ d⁻¹90 %
extrahiert
"With a continuous flow anode, C:N ratios of 4 and 8 observed near complete remov…" · substrate=sodium acetate, HRT=28.8hAusgeschlossen: kein SI-Wert
Nitrogen Removal0,97mg N L⁻¹ d⁻¹90 %
extrahiert
"With a continuous flow anode, C:N ratios of 4 and 8 observed near complete remov…" · substrate=sodium acetate, HRT=28.8hAusgeschlossen: kein SI-Wert

Methodik

Welches System und wie es betrieben wurde

Methodik

Methodology

Two-chamber MFCs (200 mL per chamber) with graphite felt electrodes and cationic PEM were operated in three phases: (I) semi-batch anode and cathode at C:N 4, 8, 16, 32; (II) continuous anode feed and batch cathode at the same C:N ratios; (III) 100 mL reactors with different PEM sizes (4, 16 cm²) at C:N 8. Anode substrate was sodium acetate; cathode electron acceptor was sodium nitrate. Nitrogen species (NO₃⁻, NO₂⁻, NH₄⁺) and total nitrogen were measured by ion chromatography and TOC analyzer. Cathode potentials were measured vs. Ag/AgCl reference and converted to SHE. Microbial community was characterized by 16S rRNA sequencing after Phase I.

Systemkonfiguration

FeldWert
reactor typeMFC
chamber config2-chamber

Betriebsbedingungen

7 Läufe extrahiert
LaufT°CpHAnolytpHKatholytSubstrat[S]mg/LHRThModusR_extΩV_appVInokulum
v2-2a3d9148c614db7d———sodium acetate—28.8—10——
v2-2c2d8f4319fd164b———sodium acetate———10——
v2-6d284c1781fb1ac7———sodium acetate—28.8—10——
v2-8bb5d4d41c186318———sodium acetate—28.8—10——
v2-a9b017c26c479a4d———sodium acetate———10——
v2-af91b7af0cd4a56f———sodium acetate—28.8—10——
v2-e09762277a28e13c———sodium acetate———10——

Extraktionspipeline

Rohextraktionen, Artefakte, Qualitätssignal

Extraktionsqualität

Ehrlichkeitssignal

Bemessen Sie Ihr Vertrauen in die extrahierten Inhalte an diesen Signalen – so hat die Pipeline ihre eigene Ausgabe für diese Publikation bewertet.

KI-Konfidenz

82 %

Vom Modell selbst angegebene Konfidenz

Mittlere Parameterkonfidenz

90 %

Durchschnittliche Konfidenz der oben angezeigten PaperParameter-Zeilen

vor dem Zitieren mit dem Quell-PDF abgleichen · Werte 0–1

03

Diagramm-Explorer

Verändern Sie die Eingaben dieser Publikation und sehen Sie, wie sich das vorhergesagte Ergebnis verschiebt.

04

Modell erkunden

Der Reaktor in 3D, mit Strömung, die sich ein- und ausschalten lässt.

05

KI-Erkenntnisse

Widersprüche, Lücken und Chancen aus dem Vergleich dieser Publikation mit dem Korpus.

06

Ähnliche Publikationen vergleichen

Die nächsten Publikationen nach System, Materialien und Organismen, mit ihren Ergebnissen nebeneinander.

07

Quell-PDF

Die Publikation, wie sie erschienen ist.

3D-Modell wird geladen …

Repräsentatives Modell, generisches MFC

Repräsentatives Modell: MFC – zugeordnet nur anhand des Systemtyps der Publikation, nicht ihres Reaktors oder ihrer Geometrie.

MFC
System
23
Extrahierte Werte
2022
Jahr

Schlagwörter

  • Denitrifying bacteria
  • Microbial fuel cell
  • Environmental chemistry
  • Denitrification
  • Anode
  • Wastewater

Zitieren

Cynthia J. Castro, Kamal Ziad Taha, Itzé Kenney et al. (2022). The Role of Carbon to Nitrogen Ratio on the Performance of Denitrifying Biocathodes for Decentralized Wastewater Treatment. Water. https://doi.org/10.3390/w14193076

Zeitschrift
Water

Öffnen Sie das Modell im Labor, um alle Steuerelemente, die Parameterbearbeitung und Vorlagen-Overlays zu nutzen.

Im Labor öffnen